Distinguishing innovation ecosystems from entrepreneurial ecosystems

O ver the past few weeks, I’ve been exploring the challenge of improving the productivity of the ecosystem surrounding a research university like Purdue. There some interesting reading on the topic, but it appears to me that we are not carefully distinguishing between ecosystems designed to accelerate the formation of new companies and ecosystems designed to accelerate innovation within existing companies.

The two are different, but related. A couple of examples will illustrate the point.

The University of Cambridge anchors an important effort to accelerate the innovation within UK manufacturing firms by integrating services into their product offerings. They call this integration, rather awkwardly, the “servitization of manufacturing”.   To explore the networks that accelerate this work, they’ve produced a useful working paper, Thriving in Open Innovation Ecosystems: Towards a Collaborative Market Orientation.

In contrast, Victor Hwang, a venture capitalist, has written a valuable book, The Rainforest: The Secret to Building the Silicon Valley.  His book explores the design of startup ecosystems.

Within a research university like Purdue, we have both  a startup ecosystem and an innovation ecosystem.   By distinguishing between the two, we’ve been able to understand how the University can leverage its assets more extensively. Every research university is facing the same dilemma: finding new ways to monetize extensive assets within the university.

Distinguishing between the startup ecosystem and the innovation ecosystem provides a good starting point. In the past few months we’ve been working with our colleagues from the Fraunhofer institutes in Germany to think through how we might make our innovation  ecosystem more productive. We will be rolling out these experiments in 2014.  our exploration is framed by this strategic question:  “How do we design and strengthen the Purdue innovation ecosystem following Fraunhofer  design principles?”

Ed Morrison is Regional Economic Development Advisor for the Purdue Center for Regional Development. He is also a member of the faculty of the Purdue College of Technology, where he is engaged in innovation policy. For the past five or six years, he has been developing new approaches to strategy in open, loosely joined network. Prior to starting his economic development work, Morrison worked for Telesis, a corporate strategy consulting firm. In this position, he served on consulting teams for clients such as Ford Motor Company, Volvo, and General Electric. He conducted manufacturing cost studies in the U.S., Japan, Mexico, Canada, Italy, Sweden, and France. Morrison started his professional career in Washington, D.C., where he has served as a legislative assistant to an Ohio Congressman, staff attorney in the Federal Trade Commission, and staff counsel in the US Senate. He holds a BA degree cum laude with honors from Yale University and MBA and JD degrees from the University of Virginia.

Learning more about the “How” of clusters

Ever since Michael Porter began promoting the concept of clusters in the mid-1990s, a lot has been written about the […]

Rebuilding our industrial commons

For over 30 years, U.S. manufacturing has been in relative decline in the face of relentless competitive pressure.  Rebuilding our […]

Moving our innovation thinking from barriers to ecosystems

Introduction Commercialization of federally funded research at universities faces a bewildering array of obstacles. The reason: innovation — the translation […]

Focusing on the future of small towns

Our colleagues at the University of North Alabama and Mississippi State have introduced Strategic Doing to four small towns. (This […]

Thoughts on the emerging practice of strategy

Strategy practices that emerged from WWII are increasingly inadequate to the task of guiding today’s organizations, communities and regions. Even […]

Conducting strategy with difficult people

When we introduce ideas around agile strategy, some folks get stuck on how the jerks will react.  For example last […]